Griddle Beats the Broiler
Last night, I was spirited off to Ruth’s Chris for a free dinner. And I was scared. Why? Because I keep saying my steaks are better than theirs. What if my memory was wrong? Ack.
Today I am feeling smug, however, because I was right.
I had the cowboy ribeye (bone-in with the meat removed from the skinny end), a baked potato, a Caesar salad with anchovies, and a Chopin martini. I’ll give you my evaluation.
First off, the meat was more tender than my ribeyes. I think. It may have been that it was just juicier. I dry-age, and maybe Ruth’s doesn’t. Dry-aging reduces the water content somewhat. They may be wet-aging; women like it because you get a really wet steak. Regardless of what the deal was, the texture was a little bit like a big piece of Jell-O.
I wasn’t too excited by that. People who don’t know anything about beef think tenderness equals quality, but that’s wrong. A steak should be tender, but it shouldn’t be like eating tapioca. It shouldn’t jiggle. That’s a little off-putting. A steak should be juicy, too, but that doesn’t mean it should be so juicy that it tastes watery.
My rib eyes are very tender. They come apart with very little effort. And they’re juicy; a gorgeous red-brown fluid comes out of them, inviting you to dip bites of potato in it. But they still resemble meat. You can feel something in your mouth when you chew. In my opinion, that’s how steak is supposed to be.
The flavor of the Ruth’s steak was not what it should have been. They use some kind of strange seasoning; I can’t tell what it is. It’s all you can taste. The flavor of the beef doesn’t really come through. Furthermore, they serve the steak on a hot plate (very nice) surrounded by added butter (very nice) which burns (not nice at all) while they bring the steak to you. The flavor of burned butter is very strong, and it’s not pleasant. I’ve used tiny amounts of burned butter as a flavoring, but generally, you want to avoid letting butter brown too much.
The meat itself was low on flavor. I don’t know why. Maybe wet-aging is to blame. They failed to brown the beef properly; that would have helped. Steak should never be served grey. It should be dark brown, and it should not be brown here and there, but all over. Browning means flavor. Another thing: a cast-iron griddle or skillet used only for steak will develop a seasoning on it that flavors the meat in a way no gas broiler can imitate.
They also put way too much salt on the steak. I was dipping it in the burned butter, trying to rinse the salt off. And I salt my steaks very heavily at home.
I know I sound like I’m ripping their steak to shreds, but it was very good. Ruth’s is a wonderful restaurant. You have to understand, I’m comparing their steak to steaks that are so good I actually make moaning noises while I eat.
They served me a baked potato with butter, sour cream, and chives. I asked for butter, sour cream, and salt, but that’s not a big deal. I tried it. Guess what? Not nearly as good as my potatoes. Not even close.
For one thing, they soak the jackets with some kind of lube. Butter, I suppose. The jacket seemed very, very thin and delicate, and it was completely wet. On the inside, the potato itself seemed wet. I don’t know how they do that. Maybe they use a steamer. It wasn’t airy and light; it was heavy. My potatoes are sort of fluffy. Also, they chintzed on the toppings. If you’re not going to put at least six ounces of sour cream on a potato, don’t waste my time with it.
Another problem: they don’t burn the potato at all. My potatoes typically have a little bit of browning inside the jacket on one side. This is marvelous; it adds complexity, and it goes great with the sour cream and butter.
The butter Ruth’s uses doesn’t have garlic in it. Arggh. MISTAKE.
I didn’t finish the potato. It was very nice, but compared to my potatoes, it was sort of civilized and limp and bland. I admit, I was trying not to be a pig, and I didn’t want to finish it. But with one of my potatoes, I would have been helpless. Willpower would have wilted before it. It always has.
I like Ruth’s, and I would never turn down a Ruth’s meal. The food last night was great. But their dinners can’t compare to a home-aged steak cooked on a griddle, next to a baked potato cooked with no foil, with salt water applied to the jacket before baking. Ruth’s is not in the same class.
One more thing: my steak arrived at the table sizzling from the heat of the plate. Looks like the unfortunate “resting” fad hasn’t spread to every cook on the planet.
Try my recipe with confidence. If you like the flavor of beef, not burned butter or herbs, and you like your potatoes fluffy and light with dry, salted jackets that cry out for garlic butter, sour cream, and beef juice, you will not be disappointed.
I feel tremendous satisfaction, having succeeded in beating the pros. I worked a long time on this, and I’m thrilled at how it paid off.