I Will Rename my Pizza Peel “the Grey Destiny”

March 10th, 2010

Wudan Pizzeria

Even though last night’s pizza session at church did not work out all that well, it was highly rewarding. First of all, people came up to me when they saw me in the building and asked if I was making pizza, and after I got to work, people came into the kitchen to tell me how great it was. That’s always enjoyable. But on top of that, I learned new stuff about pizza.

I usually use the low setting on the convection oven fan, because I’ve been told higher speed means burned cheese. But last night I decided I wanted the crust cooked more, so I used a trick I came up with on my own. I put the fan on high and added olive oil to the mozzarella to prevent it from burning.

I can’t be totally sure, because the ovens acted strangely last night, but it looks like the trick worked beautifully. I plan to do it with all of my cheese Sicilians from here on out. I think butter would be better, because butter brings out the flavor of food and makes flavors mingle. Olive oil can’t do that. Most fats don’t. Chicken fat seems to do it.

I don’t know why people rave about olive oil. It’s nearly flavorless, except for the taste of olives, which isn’t really that exciting. I could eat butter with a spoon, because it tastes so good. Olive oil? No way. I believe the exaggerated response to the very mild and uninteresting flavor of olive oil is an example of herdthink. Chefs say olive oil tastes great, so people who listen to chefs say it tastes great. It’s the same phenomenon that makes people scream with excitement when Emeril uses a pepper shaker.

If the taste of olives is such a thrill, why don’t people stuff themselves with olives all day?

It’s great to be able to make pizza, and it’s even greater to have a bag of tricks I can rely on when I need a certain effect. Professional cooks all over the US tremble when their cheese suppliers vary the fat of their mozzarella, but I can take a wide range of cheeses and make excellent pizza.

You can’t tell the professionals or advanced hobbyists anything. If their pals or heroes didn’t come up with it, it can’t be right.

It amazes me how they overcomplicate pizza. They tell me I have to ferment the dough over a period of days, and that home-oven pizza is a compromise. They use complex calculations to create dough recipes. One guy suggested I use a scale that works in 0.1-gram increments. One portion of pizza dough weighs roughly 5,000 times that much. Do I really need to know whether the oregano amounts to one hundred seven or one hundred eight five-thousandths of the total mass?

Here’s how I make pizza. I mix tap water and yeast, in a fairly loose ratio. I mix non-kosher salt, flour, and pepper, equally imprecisely. The flour is any flour I feel like using, including all-purpose. I mix the water and yeast into the dry ingredients, poking the dough with my finger until it feels right. I let the dough rise until I feel like getting up from in front of the TV, which could be half an hour or two hours. I mash the dough into an oiled pan. I repeat the TV proofing period. Actually, I don’t watch much TV, so I may be at the PC or in the garage, butchering metalworking projects.

I add sauce that contains no crushed or whole tomatoes and no fresh ingredients of any kind. I add cheese from Costco and Gordon Food Service. I bake the pizza at 550 in a crummy GE oven. I flop it out onto a stone and let the bottom of the crust bake until it looks brown.

Then I eat. It’s perfect every time. Best pizza I know of.

No ten-day fermentation, no rocket-fuel-powered oven, no flour sold only by Tiffany’s. I don’t use micrometers, pyrometers, microtomes, electron microscopes, precision scales, hygrometers…nothing. The only time I measure precisely is at church, when I need fast repeatability and complete consistency, and I need to be able to scale things up and down.

I’m not saying their way doesn’t work, but I can’t see my incentive for trying it. The long fermentations, maybe, but other than that, it seems like a lot of bother to go from 98%-perfect pizza to 99%-perfect.

My way: I can have the best pizza imaginable, 90 minutes from now, starting from scratch.

Their way: I can have pizza on Saturday, if I get started today. I have to plan pizza the way I’d plan a weekend trip. What if Saturday comes and I want Chinese?

You can see why I’m not motivated.

I think the problem is that it’s so hard to get pizza right the first time, most people live in terror after that, fearing they’ll lose the secret. I know that fear. But I got over it through practice. The hundredth time you make pizza, you should be able to leave the scale and the hydrometer in the cupboard.

Some people insist on using kosher salt, in a dissolved form! How nutty is that? Kosher salt is identical to regular salt, except that it’s much harder to dissolve, and it costs more. Kosher sodium is just like non-kosher sodium. There is no specialized periodic table just for Jews. I don’t even worry about iodized versus non-iodized. Microscopic amounts of potassium iodide are impossible to taste, and even if they were not, I like the taste of iodine. It’s one of the reasons Scotch tastes good.

Pizza nuts like to talk about “authentic” pizza, dating back to the strange, unappetizing Italian product known as pizza margherita. What they fail to remember is that the people who invented and perfected pizza didn’t own bizarre modern equipment. They did what I do. They slopped it together using, at best, measuring cups and spoons. That’s authentic. Making your pizza at Livermore Labs is not.

Cooking is like painting. The greats don’t do it by the numbers. You have to loosen up and quit being afraid of the food. Precision should serve you; you shouldn’t serve precision.

Mike never measures anything, and his pizza is great. There is absolutely no hope that he’ll ever be able to pass on a recipe, but the food is top-notch.

Anyway, next time I make pizza, it’s going to be better than the last time. I’m glad the church gave me the opportunity to expand my skill set.

10 Responses to “I Will Rename my Pizza Peel “the Grey Destiny””

  1. tondelayo Says:

    Most Italian pizzerias (okay, the ones in NY) go over the top of their Sicilian style pizzas with olive oil. I understand about your butter preference, but the butter will brown at that high temp. Hey, I could be wrong . . . certainly won’t be the first time.

  2. Gerry N Says:

    Kosher salt isn’t kosher. It’s just coarser than “regular” table salt. All the gourmet salts are foolish, and full of all kinds of filth that is more or less made inert by the fact that it’s heavily salted. I like kosher salt, dunno why, it tastes good to me so I use it.

    I got a burr under my blanket a few years ago when I was smoking some home made sausages and smoked a half pound of Kosher salt. I put it in a disposable aluminum pie tin on the top shelf of my smoker. I stirred it every half hour to get it more evenly smoked and quite dark colored, I do a pound every once in a while. It’s great to put on things for smoky flavor. I found out that the Vikings liked it.

    They didn’t know about Tabasco, I guess. If the Vikings had Tabasco, we’d all speak Norwegian now. Lucky us.

    Gerry N.

  3. ErikZ Says:

    You know, I’ve been thinking more about the soda fountain thing.

    What about making your own?

    I was looking at this: http://prairiemoon.biz/cosy.html

    And I looked up on another page that you mix syrup to water 1:5

    So, for just the water and syrup you’re paying 8$ for 5 gallons, and that’s if you’re buying the flavoring from someone else instead of developing your own recipes.

    I’m not sure how much it would cost for a fountain or carbonation.

    I like this idea because of four reasons.
    1. It’s cheaper.
    2. You can use real sugar.
    3. You can tell Coke and Pepsi to play their silly “Me only!” games somewhere else.
    4. You can create new Soda flavors.

    Also, I’m glad you put pepper in your dough. When I did that my Mom looked at me like I had brain damage.

  4. Mark E Says:

    I like your way of making pizza!

    Here is something that I have done that seems to work for me. Since I have a regular 8-5 job, I have started to mix my dough before work and let it rise in the fridge (if I am doing a weeknight pizza dinner). It rises in the fridge during the day for anywhere from 7-9 hours. When it comes out I roll it out to a rough rectangle and let it rise again in an oiled pan. Makes a great sicilian. Recipe is about 95% yours.

    I actually did a side by side taste test once with the fridge risen dough and a “fresh” batch made that afternoon. My wife and I both agreed that the fridge batch had significantly more flavor than the other. Both were very good, just the one was even better. I don’t think I save any time or anything since the dough has to warm up, but it still is easy.

    Your mileage may vary.

  5. Steve H. Says:

    I’ve used butter already. That’s how I know it works. I don’t know if it works exactly as well as oil, but it does work. Nobody gives me credit for the research I do before posting. The only thing I haven’t done is a side-by-side taste test with butter and oil.
    .
    I didn’t steal this trick. When I lived in NYC, the pizzeria that made my favorite Sicilian didn’t add oil to the cheese. I’ve seen many thin pizzas made, and adding fat works just as well for thin pizza, and I’ve never seen anyone add fat to the cheese. I should also add that I’ve seen a number of people make forum posts trying to fix their burnt-cheese problems, and as far as I know, I’m the only person who suggests adding fat. So it’s not something everyone knows.
    .
    People who make a lot of pizza tend to “invent” the same tricks independently.

  6. krm Says:

    If you are ever going to get to doing a pizza place, you’ll want to develop a bit of a repetoire of styles/variations/signature editions. This sounds like a great experiment in developing your menu along iwth refining your cooking technique with an eye toward mass production.

  7. pbird Says:

    Cooking is like painting. The greats don’t do it by the numbers. You have to loosen up and quit being afraid of the food. Precision should serve you; you shouldn’t serve precision.

    Preach it brother. This is truth.

  8. walt Says:

    I have tasted olive oil here and there at various restaurants over the years, with just bread and herbs (you know, the dunk & eat thing) and enjoyed fruity ‘tone’s’ from the oil. Almost apple-like and quite tasty.

  9. Ed Bonderenka Says:

    Like Walt says, and I don’t think corn or peanut oil will work as well.
    When I lived in Italy I was surprised at how “oily” the pizza was. I first misconstrued it as “greasy” like pizza in the States. Was told that it was olive oil to keep the pizza from burning. I liked it.

  10. pbird Says:

    Dang it, I can see myself making pizza just to see how it works out….