Desperation Cheese Tactics

March 9th, 2010

This is Like Washing Q-Tips and Re-using Them

Today’s exciting food experiment: cheese dicing.

My church has no slicer. When I told them they could get a good used one for $200-$300, it seemed like they were about to go for it. Then they decided they wanted a new one. Those run $2100. So instead of having a used slicer we can put to work, we are looking forward to having a new slicer at some far-off point in the future.

The problem with having no slicer is that we have to pay for sliced and shredded cheese, which is more expensive and somewhat less tasty than loaf cheese. GFS charges $4.00 per pound for sliced provolone and $2.85 for loaf provolone. I don’t know if Costco charges different prices for sliced and shredded mozzarella.

Yesterday I decided to buy a loaf of provolone and dice it with a cleaver, while running a timer. It turns out it takes 20 minutes to dice a six-pound loaf of cheese. In case you wondered. That includes bagging and cleanup.

Slicing would take three minutes, I’m guessing. You could slice two months’ worth of cheese in hour or two and only have to clean the slicer once.

I suppose that as a dedicated Servant Leader (our church likes this term better than “volunteer”), I could buy cheese once a week and spend an hour and a half dicing and bagging it at home. There is no way I can do this at church, while dealing with pizza demands.

Given the huge cost difference between new and used slicers, I think we should go used. If we burn through ten slicers in five years, we’ll have spent the cost of one new one. And we won’t burn through them that fast unless we buy lame brands. In the meantime, the savings would pay for a new (used) slicer about every 600 pies, or once every 5 months. Faster, if we start using sliced toppings.

A new slicer would take four years to pay for itself, but it would last thirty years.

Here’s what I’m thinking. We’re going to continue buying sliced cheese until something gives.

I bought Bouncer flour at GFS. It comes in smaller bags than Golden Tiger, it’s slightly cheaper, and pizza chefs like it. I doubt I’ll be able to tell the difference. The nearest GFS sells Bouncer, Golden Tiger, All Trumps, and Primo Gusto. Rumor has it that Bouncer and Primo Gusto (the house brand at GFS) are the same thing.

I have to be at church at 4:30 today to get ready for tonight’s service. I have to sell at least 20 pies. It’s my mission in life at this point.

6 Responses to “Desperation Cheese Tactics”

  1. Rick C Says:

    Obviously you have no obligation to do this, but would you consider buying a used slicer yourself and donating it?

  2. Scott P Says:

    If you end up buying a 40Q Hobart or something similar, you can buy a cheese grater attachment for the top. Works fine, you just have to chop up a 5 lb block of cheese a bit to make it fit.

  3. Scott P Says:

    Looks like this.

  4. Elisson Says:

    Maybe you just need a honkin’ big food processor with a shredder disc. I can shred a metric buttload of cheese with my Cuisinart in no time flat – why not try that?

  5. Edward Says:

    http://www.biddergy.com/detail.asp?id=39217

    Steve – this will probably sell for $100 or less. Any interest?

    I am so enjoying your pizza travails (and learning by osmosis) that I will try to locate a good slicer and mixer for you.

  6. krm Says:

    For a durable item like the slicer, assuming a market exists where decent condition/moderately well maintained ones are available – it seems downright silly for a low volume operation like your church to buy new.
    .
    Your reasoning and cost/benefit/risk assessment looks impecable (again, assuming there are acceptable used ones available at any given time).