The Birth of the Drool
February 2nd, 2010Slobbery Instrument Starts Making Sense
The cornet is working out well.
Until today, I couldn’t make myself practice for more than 15 minutes. On the first day, I was seeing spots and feeling like I would faint, and the sounds were positively flatulent. And all I had was the mouthpiece. On the second or third day, I managed to play a G. Yesterday I managed to play “G F E” over and over. Today, I managed D, and I also started to get a sound that almost resembled a brass instrument. On top of that, I was able to practice continuously for several minutes without stopping, and I didn’t faint. And I went over half an hour total. My lip crapped out at that point, so I sat down.
I got myself a book of standards. Man, is it encouraging. One note at a time! I can’t WAIT to be able to play an entire scale so I can try this. It’s so much simpler than the piano, and presumably, sight-reading with the trumpet will help me do a better job of sight-reading on the keyboard.
People say the trumpet (cornet, whatever) is hard to play. Okay, it is. Every instrument is hard to play…WELL. But some instruments are easy to play badly, and it looks like the trumpet is one of them. If I can learn to play badly in a month, it will be fantastic. I don’t have to be Doc Severinsen to get a lot out of it.
It takes about six months to learn to play bluegrass guitar badly, because flatpicking is a set of very unnatural motions. It takes a long time to learn to play piano badly, because sight-reading is hard, and you have to play two parts at once. Trumpet seems more like the banjo. The basic mechanics aren’t that tough.
I don’t know how long it takes to get an embouchure working. At the rate I’m going, it would appear that I ought to be able to play a whole scale within a month. Once that happens, I may be able to torture the neighbors with a real song. I mean actual music. Not the horrors found in my “Play Trumpet Today” book. On March 1st, I may be playing a whole song badly! I sure hope so.
After that, road trip to Birdland. I’ll need a beret.
If I can learn to play something really engrossing, like Summertime, it will be hard to pry the horn out of my hand. That’s a slow song, loaded with improvisational inspiration. The notes will be in my head, and if I think there is any hope I can actually play them, I’ll keep trying until I have to be separated from the horn by burly EMTs and sheriff’s deputies with bean bag guns.
I don’t know all of the instruments that are easy to play badly, but offhand, I can recommend the electric bass. I played one the first and only time I picked it up. Bass players hate to hear people say things like that, but it’s true. The bass is really easy. All you have to do is find three or four notes per measure that harmonize with whatever you’re listening to, and then you play them over and over. Nobody is going to give you a scholarship to Juilliard for doing that, but it will be real music. And the sad reality is, if you’re playing rock, you could actually sit in with a band after a day, because listeners have extremely low expectations of bass players. If you’re good enough to solo, people will notice you, but if you can only play your three or four notes, 98% of the crowd will have no idea you can’t actually play. Here’s something to make bass players even madder: for most rock songs, the bass player could turn off his amp, and most people in the audience wouldn’t know the difference.
Drums. You can play the drums right now, as long as you don’t get cocky.
I hear horror stories about the violin, although I haven’t tried it. They say the hardest part is being able to stand listening to yourself while you get the pitches wrong a billion times. People say you pretty much have to start learning the bagpipes as an embryo, because it takes so long to learn the fingering and wind control. Of course, the bagpipes are, in all respects, heinous. So I can’t say I care. Now the Uillean pipes…they would be worth the effort.
The cornet is a mystery. I thought the notes the horn could play were determined solely by the pitch the lips make, plus the length of the tube. But I noticed something odd today. When I do the fingering for a certain note, but I try to play a different note (because I’m inept), sometimes it seems like I accidentally make the horn play the correct note. How can that be possible? I would think the horn’s length and the wavelengths of the sounds would relate in a pretty rigid way.
I just found a website that explains how horns work. I can’t believe I used to be an aspiring physicist. Just looking at this stuff gives me vertigo.
I remember studying forced oscillations. You can make anything oscillate at the frequency of your choice, if you’re willing to supply the energy. I don’t know if horns work that way. You would think the volume would plummet.
Anyway, this is pretty cool. It won’t be long until I’m jamming to smokin’ beats like Three Blind Mice and Frere Jacques.
February 2nd, 2010 at 4:49 PM
If I remember correctly, you can hold down the 1st and 3rd valves and by simply adjusting your lips for each note you can play “Taps”. (It’s a piece of music you can play without learning all the fingerings first, if you’re interested in that.)
February 2nd, 2010 at 6:23 PM
To build the embouchure, play long tones – and play low notes. Hold them as long as you can. Be sure you’re breathing from your diaphragm. Try to keep the tone steady – you’re building breath control. Boring but necessary.
February 2nd, 2010 at 6:40 PM
Seems like the truly horrifying boredom was the part where all I could do was make brief rude noises.
February 2nd, 2010 at 9:19 PM
Don’t forget “Hot Cross Buns”! That was the song that taught me the most in the beginning. Fortunately I lived on a farm at the time and the neighbors were relatives…
I still remember playing “America the Beautiful” on stage and getting actual compliments about my smooth and haunting tone. I gave the cornet up too soon. I still have it somewhere; I may have to pick it up again to drive my neighbors nuts. We don’t get along too well.
February 3rd, 2010 at 12:46 AM
Those are the “open tones” which are played with the lips (your embroussure), and not the valves. Each brass instrument has a set of them, and magically the bugles is only played using the open tones. The valves are there to fill in the notes between the open tones.
Here’s a sample: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UwCxco_hiQ
Cheers
February 3rd, 2010 at 10:34 AM
“Hot Cross Buns”? Wiggy, man. I still remember Miles Davis getting blown away on blotter acid and playing 79 choruses at Newport, until they had to drive him off the stage with a fire hose.
February 3rd, 2010 at 10:37 AM
“Those are the “open tones” which are played with the lips (your embroussure), and not the valves.”
.
Not clear what you’re talking about. Are you claiming that when I finger an F and play a G, it’s an open tone?
.
The existence of open tones is not what I would call a mystery. The mystery is how I can finger one note and play another.
February 3rd, 2010 at 10:58 AM
This is fun to read…you’ve made me get my horns out of the bottom of the closet and start fooling around again just because. Speaking from experience, once you get over the initial “lip” of lip development, slow and steady will yield results.
Don’t be tempted to blow them off your face because you do more damage than you’ll do good, but the fact that you can already read music and already understand the intracacies of dynamic range and intonation (without a pedal) means you’re worlds ahead of where I was when I first picked up the trumpet in 1972. Unfortunately I layed it down in the mid 1980’s and only have picked it back up again on and off in the past few years. Good luck and as I keep saying, start practicing scales and buy “Clarke Technical Studies.” (no, I don’t get $0.25 on every copy)
February 3rd, 2010 at 12:41 PM
“At the rate I’m going, it would appear that I ought to be able to play a whole scale within a month. Once that happens, I may be able to torture the neighbors with a real song.”
Squidward?
February 3rd, 2010 at 12:45 PM
You can sharp or flat any note on the trumpet a fair amount just with your embroussure. The lower the note the easier it is to do that. In fact some of the very low notes can be produced with more than 1 set of fingerings. How the physics on that works I have no idea.