Hard to Bear
November 16th, 2026Well-Meaning Wife Deploys Nonlethal Weapon on Friendlies
I am doing nothing at all today. This is not exactly unusual, but today it’s because we had a stressful event. My wife maced herself and our toddler son in the kitchen.
It was not deliberate. She is not insane. She is just not the kind of person you want to trust around anything sharp or breakable.
Days ago, she was in the yard with Young Tarzan the Super Toddler, and two dogs approached. There were across our fence, in our pasture, and they charged the fence and barked and so on, showing hostile intent.
She grabbed the boy and ran into the house. She was out of breath when she came in. I was not pleased with whatever jackass let the dogs out.
I haven’t gotten her up to speed on carrying and shooting, so it is not realistic to hand her a shotgun right now and tell her to do what has to be done. I made the brilliant decision of turning to bear spray. I ordered her a can of the very best.
It turns out this is not a simple topic. There is more to it than pointing and shooting.
First of all, bear spray can be stronger, legally, than annoying-person spray. It can be 50% stronger than the most potent spray for deterring human beings.
Second, forget those stupid percentages you see on cheap spray at Walmart or wherever. They mean nothing. The spray I bought is 2% “major capsaicinoids.” Other sprays may boast figures like 10%, but they are much weaker. The 10% refers to something else. Not refined chemicals created to incapacitate huge carnivores that think hikers smell like Funyuns and Fiddle Faddle.
It is unbelievably nasty.
Let’s digress.
Can I legally shoot a dog that menaces a human being?
The first point to make here is that I don’t care. If you are about to do serious harm to a human being, especially my beautiful baby son, I will kill you without thinking about the law. I will kill any number of people before I will let him be hurt seriously. Prison means nothing to me compared to seeing my son live unharmed. I have already proven I mean this by committing a felony by making a cop chase me to the ER.
The cop didn’t care, either. He understood I was trying to save a life.
If I will kill multiple human beings to protect my son (or any innocent person), what do I care about shooting a dog? You can take Lassie, Benji, Beethoven, Rin Tin Tin, Huckleberry Hound, Cujo, Snoopy, Toto, Scooby-Doo, Scrappy-Doo, Old Yeller, and all 101 Dalmatians and stand them in a line, and I will gladly take a Barrett .50 BMG and put a single round through the lot of them to protect a person. An innocent person, that is.
But I did look up the law, and in Florida, it is very bad news for trash who own dogs. Criminally, nothing can happen to me, and civilly, damages are very limited. Certainly less painful than the damage of having my son’s face torn half off by some compensating moron’s Cane Corso.
Killing a dog is not murder or dogslaughter or anything like that. No matter how much you love Fluffy the inbred Rottweiler, he is property, not a person.
I’m allowed to shoot. Is spray allowed? I would guess that the biggest risk is that a finder of fact could decide I wasn’t sufficiently provoked, making me liable to an animal cruelty charge. Still an acceptable risk.
Another important point: court actions depend on evidence, and it will be pretty tough for anyone to come up with any physical evidence if I terminate a vicious dog on my big rural property surrounded by trees.
Dogs are extremely dangerous to children. The thing I mentioned–removing faces–actually happens. They have also amputated limbs.
In Florida, anyone who comes within 7 yards of you and appears inclined to do, and capable of doing, serious harm with a contact weapon can be shot without consequences. Except for the attacker. It varies with the facts, but this is the standard prosecutors like to apply.
A dog can move at least three times as fast as a person, so to me, that means about 70 feet, so call it 100 yards just to be safe. That’s when the gun should be taken out and aimed. There is no point in waiting until the last second. There is no law against brandishing a gun at an animal. there is no such thing as bare assault where animals are concerned. If the dog runs the other way, well and good. A relief to all concerned. If not, you were ready, not fumbling around trying to get your gun under control like a female Secret Service DEI hire failing to look after a president.
I would hate to harm someone’s pet and put them through the experience of wondering what happened to it, or the misery of learning that it was shot, but people have to be protected, and if your dangerous dog menaces me, it’s 100% your fault. Swallow your guilt pill. Don’t try to force it on me.
Very unpleasant topic. Here’s hoping we don’t see any more problem dogs here.
Anyway, enough about the law.
I got bear spray without really understanding what it was like. I knew it was no fun to be hit with it, but that was about all.
My wife is known for having little accidents. Today, she tried to take the bear spray out of the blister pack. She was standing at the kitchen counter near my son. I heard a scream and got up to see what was happening. She had somehow managed to defeat the safety tab thing, shooting herself in the chest in the process.
I didn’t think it was a big deal until I inhaled.
I was maybe 25 feet away when my wife maced herself, and I was not hit, but the air in the kitchen made me start coughing immediately. There was no way I could stay in that room.
My son looked fine until he took a breath. Then the tears and yelling started.
I opened a bunch of doors and windows. My wife ran out into the yard with my son. She had to get rid of her dress. She was out there in a towel. I had to delete two security videos.
I must have blown my nose 80 times. My head feels empty, even more than usual.
I would guess it took me half an hour to feel comfortable in the house again. My wife and son sat on the porch swing for over an hour. The residue from the spray burned his eyes. She thought we should take him to the ER, but I assured her that he was going to be just fine as long as she didn’t mace him again.
I took her clothes to the laundry room. There was very, very little spray on them, but the air in there was very unpleasant. I had to run everything through the washer.
I love hot peppers. I always figured I would be better prepared for pepper spray than other people. If I am, may God pity them.
I have read some interesting things about this spray.
The web says you should shoot bear spray low, to create a cloud the bear will not want to walk through. The product label, to the contrary, says to shoot it into the animal’s face.
If you don’t shoot this stuff low, you will create a very obnoxious cloud, and it is highly likely you will catch enough of it to make you miserable.
So what do I think of the product now?
I never trusted bear spray in the past, and that has not changed. I have read about the dubious statistics saying it’s more effective than guns. I think that’s propaganda. When you read about a study involving a controversial topic, expect it to agree with whoever commissioned the study. When I see a study commissioned by people who have been bitten by bears, I will take it seriously. I read enough about the spray-touting studies to convince me I should not trust them.
I don’t think spray is as good as a gun, for a person who is armed correctly and capable of shooting in a crisis. Of course, a person who can’t shoot a gun in a crisis can’t spray in a crisis, either.
I believe the odds are way over 50% that a person who sprays a vicious animal will also get a hefty dose of spray. This does not happen with guns. Unless you are lucky enough to have a breeze that carries the spray a) toward the animal and b) away from you, you can expect to be in extreme misery for at least 30 minutes. How does that affect your odds of survival?
Say you spray a bear. The bear is not impressed. You get a faceful of capsaicinoids. You will definitely be impressed.
Running is going to be pretty difficult. You may be unable to see. Breathing will be tough. If you also have a gun, you are going to have a very hard time using it. You may very well find yourself on the ground coughing, blinded, and unable to help yourself.
In that situation, was spray the right choice?
Seems to me you should shoot first and spray later. An angry bear you have shot is no more dangerous than an angry bear you have sprayed, so shooting first shouldn’t cost you much in terms of safety. You can still spray, and if spray works on an intact bear, it should also work on one with a bullet in its face. A bear you have shot successfully is no longer a threat, and if you shoot it unsuccessfully, the fact that you have fired will not prevent you from spraying later.
People think bears are like tanks, and nothing short of a bazooka will stop them, but people have killed them with .22 rifles and .40 S&W pistols. For a long time, the world-record grizzly kill was a bear a lady killed with a .22 rifle. Shot placement is everything.
It’s easier to hit a bear with spray than a bullet. That’s an advantage that has to be considered.
If you’re in a group, and you shoot a bear, the other people are free to make their own decisions. If you spray the bear, they are likely to end up on the ground with you, hacking and slinging snot everywhere. Should you force that on them?
Why aren’t the spray proponents even mentioning the problems a cloud weapon presents? Again, I think their agenda is at work.
Here I am, trying to figure out bear protection when dogs are much more likely to attack.
I think spray should do the job with most dogs. A gun is much, much better. As for bears, I guess I would carry both types of weapons and hope for the best.
Lots of uncertainties to be considered. I see no clear best path. I can’t come up with a flow chart. Everything will depend on the situation.
I should get a donkey. It would kill or maim any dog that didn’t run off immediately. But I would have to feed it and pay vet bills and whatever.
I told my wife I’m crossing “Bear” off the can label and writing “Wife.”